What is permanent? Nothing in this world is really totally permanent, but are there some things or some places that are more permanent than others? Does our concept of permanence affect how we live?
We woke up to the rumble of tracks. Looking through our slated kitchen window we saw a pair of 320 Cat excavators moving along the river bank behind our garden. We heard rumors that a second road was to be constructed along the river bank, but had no way of knowing when. Hurrying out to the garden hoping against the destruction of our corn crop, Moringa seedlings and fence, we watched as the excavators efficiently leveled the river bank and uprooted trees and bamboo. Villagers moved fences and chicken coops out of the way of the dirt movers.
 |
| Our Garden...almost gone! |
Our garden was spared…at least at this pass. Neighbor’s land and gardens weren’t as lucky. Many lost fruit trees, chicken yards, bamboo groves, land; a second road in the name of progress.
We were shocked not so much at the sudden change of the landscape…but more by the fact that in the name of progress something that many may consider ‘theirs’ or ‘permanent’ is not so. Our perspective is notably western and so we really can’t comment on what our neighbors felt, but that hasn’t stopped us from examining our own thoughts on the matter.
 |
| Our New "Cliff" |
In the past we may have glimpsed insight into villager’s ideas of ‘permanence’ or ‘ownership’ of land and resources. MCC has held village trainings trying to encourage communities to develop conservation plans for their forests so that harvesting Non-Timber Forest Products remains sustainable for years to come. These trainings have had limited success.
 |
| Playing on the New "Road" |
We wonder if this response is tied to an understanding of permanence…an understanding of ownership. Why should I harvest sustainably if there is no guarantee that the forest will be there in years to come? Why should I care for land that may not be mine? What benefit is it to me? Same is the thought process of renters of cars and homes who care little for the leased item save for a security deposit. It may be a sad insight into the human condition; ‘If it’s not mine why should I care?’
 |
| The New Road Along the River |
On the flip side I am struck by some of the responses of our neighbors to the change at the river. One neighbor commented to me, “Isn’t it beautiful?” I suppose development is beautiful to many…and maybe in the end it will be a nice road. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder, right? Our landlord shared that he is happy with the change…and mentioned plans for anther shop by the new road (precisely where our garden is). While I was personally saddened by both comments I realized that my perspective considers nature beautiful and holds land as something to be cared for and nurtured. So putting those feelings aside I tried to look on the positive side. It certainly is a challenge to live as a good steward caring for and cultivating the world around me that is not in any way permanent.
What can I learn from this? Maybe we in the West hold onto things too tightly? After all nothing in this world is permanent.
“Heaven and earth will pass away, but my words will never pass away.” Matthew 24:35